The best countertop ice makers, according to experts
These countertop ice makers will make sure you always have ice at the ready.
The Thereye ice maker has one of the largest production capacities of any ice maker we recommend — it can produce 30 pounds of ice per day with the first batch ready in just 15 minutes, according to the brand. The machine itself can hold up to 3.3 pounds and has a self-cleaning function that can be activated with the click of a button. There are two ways to refill this ice maker: manually through the water reservoir, or you can connect the 10-foot inlet hose to your water line which will automatically refill water as you need it.
Capacity: 3.3 lbs| Size: 17.63 x 10.43 x 17.72 inches| Daily Production: 30 lbs l | Ice Type: Nugget| Weight: 39.8 lbs
This option from Newair is another one of Swain’s favorites as it creates softer, ‘chewable’ ice and has a sleek, minimalistic design that can blend seamlessly into modern kitchens. Leandro DiMonriva, the creator and host of The Educated Barfly and a mixologist, also recommended this ice maker which he primarily uses for crushed ice cocktails like a mint julep. It has a 44-pound production capacity, self-cleaning feature and can store 1.5 pounds of ice at a time. Its viewing window helps you keep an eye on how full the machine is.
Capacity: 1.5 lbs | Size: 15 x 9.84 x 16.54 inches| Daily Production: 44 lbs| Ice Type: Nugget | Weight: 34 lbs
Swain recommended the Magic Chef ice maker as it’s considerably lighter than most other ice makers on the market. It can produce 27 pounds of ice in one day, according to the brand. This ice maker also has a digital control panel that lets you know when the storage bin (which can hold 1.5 pounds) is full. There are two different sizes of ice bullets you can choose from, depending on your preference.
Capacity: 1.5 lbs | Size: 15.4 x 11.7 x 15.7 inches | Daily Production: 27 lbs l | Ice Type: Bullet | Weight: 17.8 lbs
Frigidaire makes some of the best affordable ice makers, according to McHugh. This ice maker can produce as much as 26 pounds of ice per day and store up to 1.7 pounds of ice at a time, according to the brand. One batch of ice takes around nine minutes, on par with other ice makers on this list.
Capacity: 1.7 lbs | Size: 13.5 x 10 x 14 inches | Daily Production: 26 lbs | Ice Type: Bullet | Weight: 17.16 lbs
If you’re looking for clear, large cubes, ideal for spirits on the rocks, DiMonriva suggested buying this ice maker from Klaris. Unlike other models, which are sold according to their production capacity, this model produces 2-inch by 2-inch ice cubes within 8 to 10 hours, according to the brand. This is much slower than any other option on our list but can produce ice cubes that won’t immediately melt when added to your mixed drinks.
Capacity: N/A | Size: 9 x 9x 12 inches | Daily Production: N/A | Ice Type: Cube | Weight: 9 lbs
Ice makers are not designed to keep ice frozen — ice will eventually melt in your ice maker and make its way back into the water reservoir. The purpose of an ice maker is to make ice for immediate or quick use only. That said, commercial ice makers do sometimes have insulation built-in, but they’re an exception
“The consideration should always be ‘what am I going to do with this ice machine?” says DiMonriva. “The style of drinks you make will ultimately determine what you buy.” Here are other factors to keep in mind:
Maintenance: Nearly all of our recommended ice makers come with self-cleaning features, which help ensure your ice maker will always be ready to use.
Ice size: Camper English, a cocktails and spirits writer expert and author of “The Ice Book,” also recommended keeping your favorite drink in mind while shopping for an ice maker.” Do you and your family mostly drink sodas, iced tea and other non-alcoholic beverages? Then the size of the ice from the machine isn’t as important,” he says. “If you’re trying to make craft cocktails, bigger cubes are often better because they dilute more slowly.
Durability: Swain recommended staying away from budget ice makers, or spending much less than $300. “Expect your ice maker to call it quits after a year when buying on a budget.” A good ice maker can last you up to five years, or even longer depending on usage.
“At the end of the day look for clean, clear ice and don't be afraid to invest in quality,” adds McHugh.
At Select, we work with experts who have specialized knowledge and authority based on relevant training and/or experience. We also take steps to ensure all expert advice and recommendations are made independently and without undisclosed financial conflicts of interest.
Erin Swain is a sommelier, mixologist and culinary expert. She hosts a wine education podcast, mixology virtual classes and is a contributing wine writer at Hearst magazines.
Camper English is a clear ice expert and author of The Ice Book: Cool Cubes, Clear Spheres, and Other Chill Cocktail Crafts.
Kyle J McHugh is a west coast brand ambassador for Bulleit Frontier Whiskey. Kyle has spent over 16 years in the distilled spirits industry. He has also served as the president of the Sacramento Chapter of the United States Bartenders Guild.
Leandro Pari DiMonriva is the Writer, Producer, Host and Co-Creator of The Educated Barfly.
Nishka Dhawan is the associate commerce editor at Select and has written about the beverage industry for over two years. For this article, she interviewed published authors, bartenders and mixologists to learn about the best ice makers.
Catch up on Select's in-depth coverage of personal finance, tech and tools, wellness and more, and follow us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter to stay up to date.
